I remember a time when my 4 year old son wanted to wear his sister’s clothing. Why? Because girl’s clothing and accessories are awesome! Who can blame him! The colors, the glitter, the sparkles, the different textures. Ahh! The former fashion enthusiast in me gets excited just talking about it. I’ve always had an appreciation for the arts (pictures, fashion, music, dance). In high school I attended the High School of Fashion Industries in NYC. While I learned that I don’t exactly have the talent or drive for that industry, I still appreciate fashion as an art form. I love being able to express myself in my clothing, hair, make-up. I see that same appreciation in my son. But I lament that he will not be able to express himself as freely as I or another woman would without suspicion and question of his sexual and gender identity in the Christian community. We’ve had to teach my son (now 6), that he can’t wear those things because he is a boy. And honestly it breaks my heart!
Ok before a bunch of you disown me and unsubscribe, let’s establish a few things. I am a bible toting Christian. I believe God created man and woman, and does not make mistakes. I think everyone should identify as a cisgender male or female. I believe those who identify as transgender are people who are loved by God (and me) and should be treated with kindness and dignity. But I do believe that they have a mental illness that should be treated and not encouraged.
So what's my issue? I hate that we have to follow arbitrary societal norms, and push our kids to follow suit just to secure their sexual identity. We live in a society that is blurring and erasing gender completely. As a believer, how do we embrace God’s design for cisgender males and females without isolating those who don’t fit into our cultural stereotypes? I wonder if our traditional/narrow guidelines for sexual identity are actually causing some kids to question their God given gender? I say some because I recognize that gender dysphoria is much more complex than this. Is a boy who dances ballet and likes glitter any less of a boy than a football player? Is a girl who hates dresses and make-up and wants wrestle any less of a girl? No, a person’s gender is determined by God and executed in the complex genetic laws of nature He created. The DNA does not lie. My son is and will always be a boy no matter what he does or wears, because that is how God made him.
There is definitely a large part of me that would freak out internally if my son dressed in traditional girls clothing. I too am indoctrinated in our 21st-century American gender rules. My son no longer asks to wear the glittery things his sisters wear. When they dress in their multi-color tutus, I still see the twinkle in his eye. The desire to create and express himself visually. I watch as he combs thru his drawer of stripe and plaid round collar shirts looking for something of interest. For now, Disney and Pixar-themed character shirts will suffice. We’ll see what the future holds. |
Comments

This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteWe were having a conversation the other day about why so many men in Broadway are homosexual. Maybe it is because we are telling them as young theater-loving kids that this isn't something a straight man could love and do for a living, when in reality it absolutely is. Great read, and I'm looking forward to future posts!
ReplyDeleteThanks so much Robert! I completely agree. It also saddens me to think about talented kids that don't explore their passions because of how they might be perceived. Praying God gives us wisdom to break away from these toxic norms.
DeleteThanks for sharing. When my son went to preschool his teacher would tell me that he loved wearing princess costumes during playtime. Of course this completely worried my husband. But Instead of making a big deal about it I came to the realization of course he wants to wear princess costume. Because I have three boys and we live in a boy world in our home. I would tell him how fun you get to dress up. But I also went on to Amazon to buy some cool boy costumes to donate to his class. And by the end of that school year he was wearing a firman costume. At home we don’t really say boy or girl toys they have a varying range of toys. They play with baby dolls and I tell them you will be an awesome dad one day.
ReplyDeleteThanks so much for reading and sharing. It think it's great that your boys are with all kinds of toy. My kids do as well.
DeleteGreat post. I think it's not just the Christian community that would "question" his identity. I think the society in this country (America) as a whole tends to do that. It's more of a cultural issue than a religious one really. I grew up in a largely muslim country and the things that are "normal" for men to do and say there, are actually considered "girly" in the U.S.
ReplyDeleteSometimes, when I see certain faith traditions get hung up on whether women should wear trousers, I remind them that Jesus likely didn't wear "pants" back in the day LOL.
At the end of the day, I think C.S. Lewis had a really good take on modesty and dress in his book "Mere Christianity". I've since come to the conclusion that everything boils down to intent. When you wear whatever you wear, what is your intent? What is your heart? Is your heart aimed at being seductive? Is your heart aimed at deceiving others into believing that you're something you're not? Is your heart aimed at offending (e.g. wearing shirts with slur words)?
Great points. I love the CS Lewis reference. Intent is what matters most. I also agree that its a cultural/societal issue and not a religous issue per se. But within our American Christian community we sometimes use the Word of God to reinforce societal norms and sometimes do more harm than good, which I suspect might be the case here.
Delete